Consumer Contract Regulations, Buying Gifts: A Sample Case

For his wife Hilary’s birthday Sean buys several items from several online shops. They include a DVD, a personalised diary with his wife’s initials embossed on the front, some underwear and some makeup. Unfortunately he isn’t used to online shopping or using a computer. The personalised diary has the wrong initials on the front and the underwear is three sizes too big. The wife loves the makeup but it gives her an allergic reaction. The DVD turns out to be counterfeit and the man’s credit card details are stolen from the site.
Bank Card Fraud
Sean tries to use his bank card but the transaction is declined. He is puzzled by this and goes to a cash machine to see whether any large bills have been paid that he has forgotten about. He telephones his bank, and they put a stop on the card and order a new card and pin number. Sean contacts the police to report the crime, and gives them details of the websites he used.Reporting the Crime
He then emails the website from which he bought the counterfeit DVD, but receives no response. Further investigation reveals that the site provides no telephone number or postal address. Sean contacts FACT, the Federation Against Copyright Theft and reports the crime. As he has paid by debit card, rather than credit card, he cannot claim for a refund under the Consumer Credit Act.Contacting the Vendors
Because Sean has used a number of different vendors he must contact each of them separately. At first he contacts the website company that sold him the diary. It is a reputable international website, with a good reputation for quality leather goods.Unfortunately, the reply is not what he wants to hear. Goods that have been personalised in any way, or made to order, are exempt from the distance selling regulations which means that there is no automatic right to a refund or a replacement. When the store shows him his order form, it transpires that he was the one who made a mistake with his wife’s initials. If it had been a store error, he would have been entitled to a replacement or a refund.
Hilary contacts the shop that sold her husband the makeup and tells them about the allergic reaction she had suffered. They are extremely apologetic, and offer her a full refund. Hilary also writes to the manufacturer, explaining the details of her reaction to the makeup. She is sent free vouchers by way of compensation. If the makeup had not been defective in this way, and Hilary had opened the makeup and used it (accepted it) she would not have been entitled to a replacement or a refund afterwards.
Sean then contacts the underwear shop and tells them that he wants to reorder the underwear in a different size. They agree to a replacement as long as Hilary has not worn the underwear and the labels are still intact. Sean is given a freepost address to which to return the underwear. A week later, the replacement underwear arrives and finally, Hilary has a birthday present she can enjoy.
Re: The Regulations Of Privacy Policy and Internet Shopping
Hi I ordered a coffee machine online (a bundle deal - at sale price) and the transaction…
Re: Buying Clothing Online: Consumer Rights, Refunds and Returning Clothing Items
I bought some boxer briefs online and when they arrived the box…
Re: Misleading Advertising and Online Shopping
I ordered a weighted hula hoop which was marked on a sale price but when the item arrived it was completely…
Re: Can Websites Change Prices Once Ordered?
Hi, hope someone can clear this up… ordered garden furniture in May with ETA of end July/beginning of August. Paid…
Re: Can a Website Advertise Items as In Stock When They are Not?
I made a order at jcpenny and after a few days they canceled a item saying they no longer…
Re: Buying Clothing Online: Consumer Rights, Refunds and Returning Clothing Items
My daughter, bought £100 worth of clothes from AX Paris which…
Re: Can a Website Advertise Items as In Stock When They are Not?
I was seriously assaulted, meaning my Nursing career ended and I am now on benefits. It…
Re: Your Rights When Using Internet Auction Websites
Hey there does anyone know if there is a specified time for finish of an online auction does it have to…
Re: Can a Website Advertise Items as In Stock When They are Not?
I am getting really fed up with this practice. Numerous times recently I have ordered…
Re: Can a Website Advertise Items as In Stock When They are Not?
The Law hasn't moved with the times. There should be a clause in the law making it…